Evaluation of real time polymerase chain reaction targeting mpb64 gene for diagnosis of extrapulmonary tuberculosis

Paucibacillary nature of extrapulmonary tuberculosis (EPTB) has paved way for molecular methods increasingly being used for diagnosis. We undertook a study for evaluation of sensitivity and specificity of real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) targeting mpb64 gene for diagnosis of EPTB.

A total of 152 clinical samples from suspected cases of EPTB were included in this study. All samples were extracted using spin column based commercial DNA extraction kit and were subjected to RT-PCR targeting mpb64 and IS6110. Smear and culture was also done for samples whenever quantity was sufficient. Cytology report was noted from hospital information system. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was done for determining cut-off Ct value for mpb64 RT-PCR. Melt curve analysis was done for samples whose cycle threshold (Ct) value was more than 37. The sensitivity and specificity of the mpb64 RT-PCR was calculated using a composite gold standard i.e., positive for one or more of the following: microscopy (including fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), acid-fast bacilli positivity), culture and IS6110 RT-PCR.

Out of the 152 samples, 72 (47.4%) were positive for tuberculosis by composite gold standard. Samples consisted of ascitic fluid (12), CSF (35), pus (23), lymph node aspirate (35), pleural fluid (37), synovial fluid (4), urine (1), pericardial fluid (1) and tissue bits (4). Microscopy (AFB smear including lymph node aspirate) was done for 124 samples of which 43 (34.7%) were positive. Culture results were available for 79 samples, 25 (31.6%) of which were positive and 42 (27.6%) of the 152 samples were positive by IS6110 PCR. Based on ROC and melt curve analysis, mpb64 RT-PCR was able to detect 38 (52.8%) of the 72 positive samples. In comparison to IS6110 RT PCR, 4 additional cases were detected by mpb64 RT-PCR. Compared to composite gold standard mpb64 showed overall sensitivity of 52.8%.

The mpb64 RT-PCR is highly specific or MTB and can be used as a supplemental test for diagnosis of EPTB along with other diagnostic tests. However the overall sensitivity of mpb64 RT-PCR is too low to be used as an independent test for diagnosis of EPTB. Combining the results of IS6110 RT PCR and mpb64 RT PCR improved the overall sensitivity and hence mpb64 can be used as an additional target for diagnosis of EPTB.