Comparison of spirometry and impulse oscillometry in methacholine challenge test for the detection of airway...

Airway hyper-responsiveness (AHR) is a characteristic feature of asthma. The aim of this study was to compare the impulse oscillometry (IOS) and spirometry to methacholine for AHR detection among individuals with clinically hyper-reactive airway disease suggestive of bronchial asthma and baseline spirometry were normal.

Adults with symptoms suggestive of AHR and normal baseline spirometry test were selected. The short protocol of methacholine challenge test (MCT) was performed for all subjects using IOS and spirometry simultaneously. The primary endpoint was to compare the methacholine dosage causing a 20% drop in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), with methacholine dosage that causing 40% increasing the baseline respiratory resistance at 5 hertz (R5), as measured by IOS.

A total of 235 participants were analyzed, 184 (78.2%) had positive test results with R5, while 81 (34.4%) had positive MCT results with FEV1.The sensitivity and specificity of MCT with R5were 87.3%, 64.6%, and MCT with FEV1 were 39.1%, 85.4%, respectively. The area under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was greater at lower doses of MCT at R5, (AUROC: 0.653; p= 0.01).

The results showed higher sensitivity, negative predictive value, and earlier response of the short protocol of MCT with IOS, compared to MCT with spirometry. Our study suggested the utility of IOS in addition to conventional spirometry as a method of choice in MCT for detection of AHR.