Systematic comparison of ligand-based and structure-based virtual screening methods on poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase-1...

The poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase-1 (PARP1) has been regarded as a vital target in recent years and PARP1 inhibitors can be used for ovarian and breast cancer therapies. However, it has been realized that most of PARP1 inhibitors have disadvantages of low solubility and permeability. Therefore, by discovering more molecules with novel frameworks, it would have greater opportunities to apply it into broader clinical fields and have a more profound significance. In the present study, multiple virtual screening (VS) methods had been employed to evaluate the screening efficiency of ligand-based, structure-based and data fusion methods on PARP1 target. The VS methods include 2D similarity screening, structure-activity relationship (SAR) models, docking and complex-based pharmacophore screening. Moreover, the sum rank, sum score and reciprocal rank were also adopted for data fusion methods. The evaluation results show that the similarity searching based on Torsion fingerprint, six SAR models, Glide docking and pharmacophore screening using Phase have excellent screening performance. The best data fusion method is the reciprocal rank, but the sum score also performs well in framework enrichment. In general, the ligand-based VS methods show better performance on PARP1 inhibitor screening. These findings confirmed that adding ligand-based methods to the early screening stage will greatly improve the screening efficiency, and be able to enrich more highly active PARP1 inhibitors with diverse structures.