CD56 expression in basaloid anal squamous cell carcinoma - A potential diagnostic pitfall

Anal squamous cell carcinoma (SqCC) is a morphologically heterogeneous entity. Basaloid and non-keratinizing anal SqCC may be confused with other tumors including neuroendocrine carcinoma due to morphologic overlap, and expression of neuroendocrine markers is not well-studied in anal SqCC. Prompted by a case of anal SqCC that was initially misdiagnosed as neuroendocrine carcinoma on the basis of morphology and CD56 expression, we retrospectively examined the expression of neuroendocrine markers CD56, synaptophysin, and chromogranin in 48 cases of basaloid anal SqCC, with clinicopathologic correlation. HPV16 was identified in 46 cases, HPV33 in one case, and one case was HPV-negative. Three (6.3%) cases demonstrated CD56 expression, including two with diffuse and one with focal expression. Two CD56-positive cases demonstrated basaloid morphology with peripheral palisading and the other demonstrated adenoid cystic/cylindroma-like morphology. None of the cases showed significant synaptophysin or chromogranin expression. The three cases expressing CD56 were HPV16-positive, and one demonstrated a CTNNB1 mutation. There was no difference in clinicopathologic features including stage, outcome, or HPV status, between CD56-positive and negative groups. Our findings support that CD56 expression is infrequently expressed in anal SqCC and is not indicative of neuroendocrine differentiation in the absence of expression of more specific neuroendocrine markers such as synaptophysin and chromogranin. Pathologists should be aware that CD56 expression may occur in basaloid anal SqCC and is a diagnostic pitfall due to morphologic overlap with neuroendocrine carcinoma and other tumors including basal cell carcinoma.