Does synaptic hypometabolism or synaptic dysfunction, originate cognitive loss? Analysis of the evidence

Elderly persons with currently normal cognition who have cerebral hypometabolism as shown by low uptake of ¹⁸fluorine-fluorodeoxyglucose (¹⁸F-FDG), are at risk of future loss of cognition and, thus, of future Alzheimer's dementia (AD). Reduction of either ¹⁸F-FDG or cognition is assumed to reflect synaptic dysfunction, since synapses account for the majority of glucose use by the brain and cognition depends upon accurate synaptic function. The chronology of the connection between reduced cerebral synaptic function and hypometabolism is, therefore, a critical question, because if synaptic dysfunction came first, then correcting the hypometabolism would likely not benefit synaptic function; but if hypometabolism came first, then correcting the hypometabolism probably would benefit synaptic function. That correction might prevent initiation of the cognitive loss that eventuates in AD and, thereby, would benefit the vast numbers of persons in their eighth to tenth decades of life who are at risk for AD. Among the many citations reviewed in this presentation, seven show hypometabolism that precedes synaptic dysfunction, and two show the reverse. Thus the preponderance of evidence, 78%, suggests that the initiating event is synaptic hypometabolism and that it is 3.5-fold less likely that synaptic dysfunction is the initiator. In addition, it is inherently unlikely that synaptic dysfunction causes hypometabolism. This conclusion could be tested by a clinical trial whose primary objective would be to assess the benefit to cognition of improving synaptic metabolism in patients who are at risk for cognitive loss.