Delivery of Antisense RNA Therapeutics: Turning Negative Results Into a Positive Development
Wouter Eilers1, Michela A Denti2
1Sutura Therapeutics, Ltd, Alderley Park, Nether Alderley, Cheshire, United Kingdom.
Abstract:
The number of novel potential RNA-based antisense therapeutics is rapidly increasing. However, efficient delivery to target tissues is still the main factor that limits their translation into the clinic. Although many groups in academia and industry are working toward the development of methods to improve antisense delivery to overcome this limitation, there are very few coordinated efforts to learn from the experience of other investigators by sharing "negative" results. In the field of nucleic acid therapeutics, or any other type of therapeutics, the ultimate aim of most research projects is to develop novel or improved therapeutic strategies. It seems only logical that experiments are thought to yield a "negative result" if there is an absence of an improvement in some parameter related to potential therapeutic efficacy. These data often do not get published in scientific journals or presented at scientific meetings. However, positive and negative results obtained from scientifically sound experiments are equally valuable in facilitating progress in the field. They avoid unnecessary duplication of experiments and allow researchers to take approaches that did not yield the predicted result into account when designing new experiments.
Insights
Sharing negative results in RNA-based antisense therapeutics research is crucial. Publishing both positive and negative findings accelerates progress and prevents redundant experiments in drug development.
Area of Science:
- Biomedical Science
- Drug Discovery
- Molecular Biology
Background:
- The development of RNA-based antisense therapeutics is advancing rapidly.
- Efficient delivery to target tissues remains a significant hurdle for clinical translation.
- Limited sharing of negative experimental results hinders collective progress.
Discussion:
- Negative results, defined as a lack of improvement in therapeutic efficacy parameters, are often unpublished.
- Publication of both positive and negative findings is essential for scientific advancement.
- Sharing negative data prevents duplication of experiments and informs future research designs.
Key Insights:
- Coordinated efforts to share negative results in antisense drug development are lacking.
- Scientifically sound negative results are as valuable as positive results.
- Publication bias towards positive outcomes can impede therapeutic innovation.
Outlook:
- Encouraging the publication and presentation of negative results will accelerate the field.
- A collaborative approach to data sharing can optimize the design of novel therapeutic strategies.
- Improved understanding of delivery challenges through shared data can expedite clinical translation.
Related Concept Videos
Experimental RNAi
siRNA - Small Interfering RNAs
In the cytoplasm, siRNA is processed from a double-stranded RNA, which comes from either endogenous DNA transcription or exogenous sources like a virus. This double-stranded RNA is then cleaved by the...
RNA Interference
This process occurs naturally in cells, often through the activity of genomically-encoded microRNAs. Researchers can take advantage of this mechanism by introducing synthetic RNAs to deactivate specific genes for research or therapeutic purposes. For example, RNAi could be used...
Types of RNA
RNA Performs Diverse...
Nonsense-mediated mRNA Decay
Usually, Upf3 binds to an Exon Junction Complex (EJC) at mRNA splice sites. If a ribosome fully translates the mRNA,...


