Does Patient Sex Affect Ultrasound Cutoff Values for Severity Grading of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?

A growing body of evidence supports ultrasound (US) as an alternative first-line confirmatory test for carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). Recent studies have demonstrated a correlation of US cross-sectional area with electrodiagnostic (EDX)-determined severity; however, it is unclear whether patient sex affects the cutoff values used for determining severity. The purpose of this study was to determine if patient sex affects US graded severity when using EDX as the reference standard.

A cohort of 367 women and 46 men, aged 18-90 years, from 1 orthopedic hand surgeon's practice underwent EDX and US. Distal motor latency and distal sensory latency of the median nerve were recorded. Severity was classified using a modified Bland severity scale. The US measurements of the cross-sectional area of the median nerve at the wrist crease were acquired by a fellowship-trained hand surgeon. Separate receiver operator characteristic curve analyses of the male and female groups were performed for US cutoff values.

The cutoff value in both the female (F) and male (M) patients was 11 mm² for mild (area under the curve = 0.76 F; 0.78 M), 12 mm² for moderate (area under the curve = 0.75 F; 0.73 M), and 13 mm² for severe (area under the curve = 0.75 F; 0.71 M) CTS. The sensitivity of the cutoffs for mild, moderate, and severe CTS in the female and male groups was 49% and 56%, 44% and 50%, and 49% and 44%, respectively. The specificity of the cutoffs for mild, moderate, and severe CTS in the female and male groups was 75% and 79%, 74% and 82%, and 83% and 78%, respectively.

Patient sex does not appear to have a significant impact on the determination of CTS severity graded using US cutoff values. Ultrasound can be used to grade the severity of CTS with a 75% to 85% specificity but low sensitivity. A cutoff value of 13 mm² can be used to classify CTS as severe.

Prognostic II.