Weakly Internalized Receptors Use Coated Vesicle Heterogeneity to Evade Competition during Endocytosis

The uptake of receptors by clathrin-mediated endocytosis underlies signaling, nutrient import, and recycling of transmembrane proteins and lipids. In the complex, crowded environment of the plasma membrane, receptors are internalized when they bind to components of the clathrin coat, such as the major adaptor protein, AP2. Receptors with higher affinity for AP2 are known to be more strongly internalized compared to receptors with lower affinity. However, it remains unclear how receptors with different affinities compete for space within crowded endocytic structures. To address this question, we constructed receptors with varying affinities for AP2 and allowed them to compete against one another during internalization. As expected, the internalization of a receptor with high affinity for AP2 was reduced when it was coexpressed with a competing receptor of similar affinity. However, receptors of low affinity for AP2 were surprisingly difficult to displace from endocytic structures, even when expressed alongside receptors with much higher affinity. To understand how these low-affinity receptors are protected from competition, we looked at AP2 heterogeneity across clathrin-coated structures. When we examined structures with lower-than-average AP2 content, we found that they were relatively enriched in cargo of low affinity for AP2 and depleted of cargo with high affinity. These findings suggest that the heterogeneity of adaptor protein content across the population of endocytic structures enables the internalization of diverse receptors. Given the critical role that internalization plays in signaling, this effect may help to prevent strongly internalized receptors from interfering with the cell's ability to process signals from weakly internalized receptors.