Metal exposure and biomarker levels among e-cigarette users in Spain

The use of electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) has increased due to the belief that they are healthier than tobacco cigarettes. E-cigarettes contain a metallic heating coil (composed of Ni, Cr, Al and other metals) to heat a solution (commonly called e-liquid) and convert it into an aerosol. This aerosol is inhaled (vaped) by the users who can be potentially exposed to a wide variety of metals. We investigated the possible transfer of metals from the coil to the e-liquid and the generated aerosol, and how the exposure to this aerosol can increase metal body burden in e-cigarette users. We recruited 75 e-cigarette users (50 who only vaped and 25 dual users who vaped and smoked) and 25 controls who neither vaped nor smoked. E-liquid samples before (dispenser e-liquid) and after (tank e-liquid) being added to their devices were collected. Aerosol samples were collected using a condensation method. All participants provided urine and hair samples. All samples were analyzed for metals by ICP-MS. We observed higher metal concentrations in the aerosol and tank e-liquid (in contact with the coil) compared to the dispenser e-liquid (before contact with the coil). The median concentrations for some of the metals with the most remarkable increases in aerosol and tank e-liquid vs. dispenser e-liquid were 36.90 and 62.73 vs. 18.29 μg/kg for Al; 6.71 and 28.97 vs. 0.98 μg/kg for Cr; 91.39 and 414.47 vs. 1.64 μg/kg for Ni; 738.99 and 744.24 vs. 16.56 μg/kg for Zn; and 10.17 and 22.31 vs. 0.88 μg/kg for Pb. We also found detectable and potentially high concentrations of other metals such as Mn, Cu, Sb and Sn. In urine, increases in the median levels (μg/g creatinine) in vapers/duals vs. controls were observed for some metals, including Cr (0.34/0.28 vs. 0.20), Cu (1.72/2.36 vs. 1.46), Sn (0.26/0.31 vs. 0.18) and Pb (0.39/0.44 vs. 0.22). In hair, there were no differences in metal concentrations among the three groups. In conclusion, e-cigarettes are likely a source of metals such as Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb or Sn. These metals come from the device, likely the heating resistance, as their concentrations were low in the dispenser e-liquid and higher in the aerosol and the e-liquid left in the tank. Although the exposure to e-cigarette aerosol can have an influence in the body burden of metals, aerosol metal levels were not clearly associated with metal levels in biological samples such as urine or hair in e-cigarette users in this study.