Characterization of Vocal Fold Pathology in Military Drill Instructors

Military drill instructors have extreme vocal demands that place them at risk for phonotrauma. Characterization of laryngeal pathology and vibratory characteristics among drill instructors presenting for specialized voice care is lacking.

A retrospective review in a specialized voice clinic over a two-year period was conducted. Patients identified as current drill instructors between the ages of 28-43 with a diagnosis of dysphonia were included. Laryngeal pathology was diagnosed by a fellowship trained laryngologist and vibratory characteristics were evaluated utilizing the Voice-Vibratory Assessment with Laryngeal Imaging (VALI) rating form. All patients were also evaluated by a speech-language pathologist. Patient reported outcome measures were collected along with perceptual voice evaluations utilizing the Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V).

Twelve current drill instructors were identified, and all had phonotraumatic lesions. Lesions were categorized as vocal fold hemorrhage (8%), ectasia (25%), unilateral epithelial thickening (33.3%), bilateral epithelial thickening (58.3%), ventricular cyst (8%), polyp (25%), and sulcus vocalis (25%). Vibratory abnormalities were assessed with the VALI rating scale and correlated to CAPE-V perceptual ratings with 83% having reduced mucosal wave, 75% reduced amplitude of lateral excursion, 50% aperiodic vibrations, 50% asymmetric or chasing wave, 58% glottal insufficiency, 100% supraglottic hyperfunction, and an average CAPE-V overall severity of 50% with severe perceptual dysphonia. The average Voice Handicap Index (VHI-10) and Reflux Symptom Index (RSI) score was 15.5 and 14.7, respectively.

Phonotraumatic lesions were universally present in drill instructors complaining of hoarseness, suggesting early referral, and intervention may be warranted in this population.

4.