A Call to Update Standard of Care for Children With Differences in Sex Development

Nat Mulkey1, Carl G Streed2, Barbara M Chubak3

  • 1Recent recipient of MD degree from Boston University School of Medicine in Massachusetts.

AMA Journal of Ethics
|August 5, 2021
PubMed

Insights

Physicians debate care for children with differences in sex development (DSD). Recent DSD-LIFE Study data are examined to determine if they support deferring non-essential early surgical interventions for DSD patients.

Area of Science:

  • Pediatric endocrinology
  • Genetics
  • Medical ethics

Background:

  • Children with differences in sex development (DSD) face complex care decisions.
  • Past early surgical interventions for DSD have led to patient suffering.
  • Calls for deferral of non-essential DSD surgeries are increasing.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To evaluate recent data regarding the care of children with DSD.
  • To assess the extent to which new data support deferring surgical interventions for DSD.
  • To inform the ongoing debate on the standard of care for DSD.

Main Methods:

  • Review of recent data from the DSD-LIFE Study.
  • Analysis of long-term outcomes related to DSD interventions.
  • Consideration of ethical and legislative trends in DSD management.

Main Results:

  • The DSD-LIFE Study provides new insights into long-term DSD outcomes.
  • Data suggest potential harms from early, unnecessary surgical procedures.
  • Evidence regarding the benefits and risks of deferral is evolving.

Conclusions:

  • The standard of care for DSD involves interdisciplinary teams and parental input.
  • Hesitancy in full deferral is linked to a lack of comprehensive long-term data.
  • Mounting legislation indicates a societal shift towards caution in DSD interventions.

Related Concept Videos

Standards of Care II01:19

Standards of Care II

Nurses bear specific legal responsibilities under several federal statutes, including:
845
Standards of Care I01:22

Standards of Care I

Federal statutes profoundly impact nursing practice, providing critical guidelines to ensure patient care is equitable, accessible, and of the highest quality. The following laws address distinct aspects of healthcare provision and patient rights:
872
Socioemotional Experience and Gender Development01:30

Socioemotional Experience and Gender Development

Social-emotional experiences and cultural influences play significant roles in shaping gender development. During middle childhood, from ages 6 to 11, peer groups become dominant in reinforcing gender norms. Children in this age group often align with same-gender peer groups, which actively encourage behaviors that conform to traditional gender roles. For instance, boys may be discouraged from engaging in activities perceived as feminine, reinforcing culturally dictated norms about masculinity...
121
Sex-linked Disorders01:43

Sex-linked Disorders

Like autosomes, sex chromosomes contain a variety of genes necessary for normal body function. When a mutation in one of these genes results in biological deficits, the disorder is considered sex-linked.
104.0K
Drug Dosing: Infants and Children01:29

Drug Dosing: Infants and Children

Pediatric patient dosages diverge from adults due to disparities in body surface area, total body water, and extracellular fluid per kilogram of body weight. The dosing regimen considers the variations in pharmacokinetics and pharmacology across distinct age groups, encompassing preterm newborns, infants, young children, older children, and adolescents. Calculation of pediatric patient doses is predicated on determining body surface area, which exhibits a superior correlation with the child's...
57
Specialized Care Centers and Settings-II01:30

Specialized Care Centers and Settings-II

Rural Health Centers
Rural health centers are specialized care facilities in remote locations with very few medical personnel. The primary care providers who run the centers are mostly Registered Nurse Practitioners. Here, emergency treatment is provided to critically ill or injured patients before they are transferred to the closest hospital. Fortunately, due to advancement in technology, many rural healthcare facilities and professionals have easy access to diagnostic and treatment...
812