Prevention in primary care: variability in physician practice patterns in New York City

We conducted a telephone survey of 120 randomly selected primary care physicians in New York City. This survey, which was completed in October 1984, concerned physicians' recommendations for health promotion and disease prevention. The recommendations by these physicians were often at variance with the recommendations of nationally recognized organizations such as the American Cancer Society and the American College of Physicians. Multivariate analysis revealed that board-certified physicians, U.S. medical graduates, and younger physicians agreed more frequently with the recommendations of national organizations. The physicians surveyed agreed upon the need to include health promotion and disease prevention in their practices. Eighty-seven percent agreed with the statement, "Physicians should probably practice more preventive medicine than they presently do." Reasons given for the failure to practice more prevention included lack of time (70 percent), inadequate reimbursement (60 percent), and "unclear recommendations" (58 percent). Approximately four out of five of the physicians felt a task force was needed to "clarify recommendations" for preventive medicine. The findings of this survey suggest a need for increased physician training and education in disease prevention and health promotion.