The Ethics of Elective Growth Hormone Therapy in Children with Idiopathic Short Stature

Kevin Leslie Kecskemeti1, Samuel Reis-Dennis2

  • 1MD Candidate 2024, Faculty of Medicine, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada. klkecskemeti@mun.ca.

Insights

Growth hormone (GH) therapy for idiopathic short stature (ISS) in children is ethically questionable. Research suggests potential risks outweigh benefits, making it unjustifiable for most cases.

Area of Science:

  • Pediatric Endocrinology
  • Medical Ethics
  • Child Health Policy

Background:

  • Idiopathic short stature (ISS) affects children without identifiable underlying medical conditions.
  • Growth hormone (GH) therapy is a treatment option for ISS, raising ethical considerations.
  • Assessing the risk-benefit profile of elective GH therapy is crucial.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To critically analyze the ethical justification of elective growth hormone therapy in children with ISS.
  • To review current clinical evidence on GH therapy's efficacy, side-effects, and risks.
  • To determine the ethical permissibility of GH therapy for ISS.

Main Methods:

  • Systematic review of recent clinical research on GH therapy for ISS.
  • Ethical analysis framework applied to treatment efficacy and safety data.
  • Evaluation of long-term outcomes and potential adverse effects.

Main Results:

  • Clinical evidence shows variable efficacy of GH therapy in increasing height for children with ISS.
  • Potential side-effects and risks associated with long-term GH administration are significant.
  • The benefits of GH therapy do not consistently outweigh the identified risks for most children with ISS.

Conclusions:

  • Elective growth hormone therapy for idiopathic short stature is ethically challenging.
  • The current evidence suggests that GH therapy is not ethically justifiable for the majority of children with ISS.
  • Further research and ethical deliberation are needed to guide clinical practice.

Related Concept Videos

Nature and Nurture01:10

Nature and Nurture

Many human characteristics, like height, are shaped by both nature—in other words, by our genes—and by nurture, or our environment. For example, chronic stress during childhood inhibits the production of growth hormones and consequently reduces bone growth and height. Scientists estimate that 70-90% of variation in height is due to genetic differences among individuals, and 10-30% of variation in height is due to differences in the environments that individuals experience,...
21.2K
Hormones and Bone Tissue01:17

Hormones and Bone Tissue

The endocrine system produces and secretes hormones, which interact with the skeletal system. These hormones control bone growth, maintain bone once it is formed, and remodel it.
Hormones That Influence Osteoblasts and/or Maintain the Matrix
Several hormones are necessary for controlling bone growth and maintaining the bone matrix. The pituitary gland secretes growth hormone (GH), which, as its name implies, controls bone growth. This happens in several ways: first, it triggers chondrocyte...
3.2K
Insulin: Dosing Regimen and Adverse Effects01:16

Insulin: Dosing Regimen and Adverse Effects

Insulin-replacement therapy usually includes both long-acting insulin (basal) and short-acting insulin (to cater to postprandial needs). In a diverse group of type 1 diabetes patients, the average daily insulin dose is typically 0.5-0.7 units/kg body weight. However, obese patients and pubertal adolescents may need more due to insulin resistance.
The basal dose constitutes about 40%-50% of the total daily dose, with the rest as premeal insulin. The mealtime insulin dose should mirror...
309
Major Hormones and Their Functions01:27

Major Hormones and Their Functions

Hormones, the biochemical messengers produced by endocrine glands, are pivotal in regulating bodily functions and maintaining homeostasis. Each hormone's balance is crucial; imbalances can lead to significant physiological disruptions. Major hormones include oxytocin, cortisol, epinephrine, estrogen, testosterone, thyroxine, growth hormone, insulin, and glucagon.
Oxytocin, produced in the hypothalamus and released by the pituitary gland, plays a role in social bonding, childbirth, and...
1.0K
What is Genetic Engineering?00:49

What is Genetic Engineering?

Overview
76.2K
Signs of Puberty01:27

Signs of Puberty

Puberty is a critical phase, typically beginning between the ages of 8 and 13 in girls and 9 and 14 in boys, though timing can vary based on genetics, environmental factors, and overall health. This period is characterized by the development of secondary sexual characteristics and the attainment of reproductive potential. Endocrine changes underpin puberty, with hormonal surges of Luteinizing Hormone (LH) and Follicle-Stimulating Hormone (FSH) instigated by Gonadotropin-Releasing Hormone (GnRH)...
754