Related Experiment Video
Updated: Oct 19, 2025
Endoscopic Bilateral Nipple-sparing Mastectomy via a Single Axillary Incision with Immediate Pre-pectoral Implant-based Breast Reconstruction
Published on: May 17, 2024
Perceived versus Patient-Reported Significance of Surgeon Gender in Breast Reconstruction
Jessica J Hsu1, Carrie A Kubiak1, Jessica I Billig1
1From the Department of Surgery, Section of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Michigan Medicine; Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan; and Consulting for Statistics, Computing and Analytics Research, University of Michigan Office of Research.
Background:
Previous investigators demonstrated that female patients often prefer female providers. However, these studies have not determined whether there are gender preferences for breast reconstruction surgeons or whether the effects of surgeon gender impacts patient-reported outcomes.
Methods:
Adult women were crowdsourced using Amazon Mechanical Turk to characterize societal preferences for the gender of breast and plastic surgeons in a hypothetical scenario. The authors also used data from the Mastectomy Reconstruction Outcomes Consortium to determine the association between surgeon gender and patient satisfaction after breast reconstruction. The BREAST-Q questionnaire was used to assess patient-reported outcomes at 3 months and 2 years following reconstruction. Regression analyses were performed to investigate the effects of surgeon gender on patient-reported outcomes.
Results:
In total, 1413 surveys were collected. Forty-two percent preferred female plastic surgeons, 5 percent preferred male surgeons, and 53 percent reported no preference. The Mastectomy Reconstruction Outcomes Consortium analysis included 2236 patients of 55 male and nine female plastic surgeons. In this cohort, 1921 patients (82.2 percent) had male surgeons, whereas 415 patients (17.8 percent) had female surgeons. Regression analysis at 2 years revealed no differences in satisfaction with surgeon, outcome, or psychosocial well-being. Only satisfaction with information differed, as patients of female surgeons reported greater satisfaction in this category, with an adjusted mean difference of 2.82 (p = 0.018).
Conclusions:
Although nonpatient women hypothetically prefer female providers, surgeon gender makes little difference in actual patient satisfaction with breast reconstruction. More investigation is needed to determine whether the difference in information delivery is clinically significant and whether it reflects variations in practices between male and female surgeons.
Clinical Question/Level Of Evidence:
Therapeutic, III.
