Birhythmicity, intrinsic entrainment, and minimal chimeras in an electrochemical experiment

The coexistence of limit cycles in a phase space, so called birhythmicity, is a phenomenon known to exist in many systems in various disciplines. Yet, detailed experimental investigations are rare, as are studies on the interaction between birhythmic components. In this article, we present experimental evidence for the existence of birhythmicity during the anodic electrodissolution of Si in a fluoride-containing electrolyte using weakly illuminated n-type Si electrodes. Moreover, we demonstrate several types of interaction between the coexisting limit cycles, in part resulting in peculiar dynamics. The two limit cycles exhibit vastly different sensitivities with respect to a small perturbation of the electrode potential, rendering the coupling essentially unidirectional. A manifestation of this is an asymmetric 1:2 intrinsic entrainment of the coexisting limit cycles on an individual uniformly oscillating electrode. In this state, the phase-space structure mediates the locking of one of the oscillators to the other one across the separatrix. Furthermore, the transition scenarios from one limit cycle to the other one at the borders of the birhythmicity go along with different types of spatial symmetry breaking. Finally, the master-slave type coupling promotes two (within the experimental limits) identical electrodes initialized on the different limit cycles to adopt states of different complexity: one of the electrodes exhibits irregular, most likely chaotic, motion, while the other one exhibits period-1 oscillations. The coexistence of coherence and incoherence is the characteristic property of a chimera state, the two coupled electrodes constituting an experimental example of a smallest chimera state in a minimal network configuration.