Oxidative Damage Blocks Thymineless Death and Trimethoprim Poisoning in Escherichia coli

Cells that cannot synthesize one of the DNA precursors, dTTP, due to thyA mutation or metabolic poisoning, undergo thymineless death (TLD), a chromosome-based phenomenon of unclear mechanisms. In Escherichia coli, thymineless death is caused either by denying thyA mutants thymidine supplementation or by treating wild-type cells with trimethoprim. Two recent reports promised a potential breakthrough in TLD understanding, suggesting significant oxidative damage during thymine starvation. Oxidative damage in vivo comes from Fenton's reaction when hydrogen peroxide meets ferrous iron to produce hydroxyl radical. Therefore, TLD could kill via irreparable double-strand breaks behind replication forks when starvation-caused single-strand DNA gaps are attacked by hydroxyl radicals. We tested the proposed Fenton-TLD connection in both thyA mutants denied thymidine, as well as in trimethoprim-treated wild-type (WT) cells, under the following three conditions: (i) intracellular iron chelation, (ii) mutational inactivation of hydrogen peroxide (HP) scavenging, and (iii) acute treatment with sublethal HP concentrations. We found that TLD kinetics are affected by neither iron chelation nor HP stabilization in cultures, indicating no induction of oxidative damage during thymine starvation. Moreover, acute exogenous HP treatments completely block TLD, apparently by blocking cell division, which may be a novel TLD prerequisite. Separately, the acute trimethoprim sensitivity of the rffC and recBCD mutants demonstrates how bactericidal power of this antibiotic could be amplified by inhibiting the corresponding enzymes. IMPORTANCE Mysterious thymineless death strikes cells that are starved for thymine and therefore replicating their chromosomal DNA without dTTP. After 67 years of experiments testing various obvious and not so obvious explanations, thymineless death is still without a mechanism. Recently, oxidative damage via in vivo Fenton's reaction was proposed as a critical contributor to the irreparable chromosome damage during thymine starvation. We have tested this idea by either blocking in vivo Fenton's reaction (expecting no thymineless death) or by amplifying oxidative damage (expecting hyperthymineless death). Instead, we found that blocking Fenton's reaction has no influence on thymineless death, while amplifying oxidative damage prevents thymineless death altogether. Thus, oxidative damage does not contribute to thymineless death, while the latter remains enigmatic.