Microbiology of barrier component analogues of a deep geological repository

Canada is currently implementing a site selection process to identify a location for a deep geological repository (DGR) for the long-term storage of Canada's used nuclear fuel, wherein used nuclear fuel bundles will be sealed inside copper-coated carbon steel containers, encased in highly compacted bentonite clay buffer boxes, and sealed deep underground in a stable geosphere. Because a DGR must remain functional for a million years, it is important to examine ancient natural systems that serve as analogues for planned DGR components. Specifically, studying the microbiology of natural analogue components of a DGR is important for developing an understanding of the types of microorganisms that may be able to grow and influence the long-term stability of a DGR. This study explored the abundance, viability, and composition of microorganisms in several ancient natural analogues using a combination of cultivation and cultivation-independent approaches. Samples were obtained from the Tsukinuno bentonite deposit (Japan) that formed ∼10 mya, the Opalinus Clay formation (Switzerland) that formed ∼174 mya, and Canadian shield crystalline rock from Northern Ontario that formed ∼2.7 bya. Analysis of 16S rRNA gene amplicons revealed that three of the ten Tsukinuno bentonite samples analyzed were dominated by putative aerobic heterotrophs and fermenting bacteria from the phylum Actinobacteria, whereas five of the Tsukinuno bentonite samples were dominated by sequences associated with putative acidophilic chemolithoautotrophs capable of sulfur reduction. The remaining Tsukinuno bentonite samples, the Northern Ontario rock samples, and the Opalinus Clay samples generated inconsistent replicate 16S rRNA gene profiles and were associated primarily with contaminant sequences, suggesting that the microbial profiles detected were not sample-specific but spurious. Culturable aerobic heterotroph abundances were relatively low for all Tsukinuno bentonite samples, culturable anaerobic heterotrophs were only detected in half of the Tsukinuno samples, and sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) were only detected in one Tsukinuno sample by cultivation. Culture-specific 16S rRNA gene profiles from Tsukinuno clay samples demonstrated the presence of phyla Bacteroidetes, Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, and Firmicutes among aerobic heterotroph cultures and additional bacteria from the phyla Actinobacteria and Firmicutes from anaerobic heterotroph plate incubations. Only one nucleic acid sequence detected from a culture was also associated with its corresponding clay sample profile, suggesting that nucleic acids from culturable bacteria were relatively rare within the clay samples. Sequencing of DNA extracted from the SRB culture revealed that the taxon present in the culture was affiliated with the genus Desulfosporosinus, which has been found in related bentonite clay analyses. Although the crystalline rock and Opalinus Clay samples were associated with inconsistent, likely spurious 16S rRNA gene profiles, we show evidence for viable and detectable microorganisms within several Tsukinuno natural analogue bentonite samples.