Risk Stratification for Revision Surgery Following Total Ankle Replacement

As a result of improved implants total ankle replacement (TAR) is becoming a more reliable option for end stage ankle arthritis. As with any surgery there are numerous complications that can occur intraoperatively and postoperatively with TAR. The primary aim of this study is to use recent data on implants currently on the market to develop a well-defined and comprehensive complication classification system which stratifies risk of subsequent surgery for TAR. A systematic review of studies on TARs from 2013 to 2018 was performed. Inclusion criteria were studies published between 2013 and August 2018, studies having at least 20 patients, data with at least 1-year follow-up and use of implants currently on the market. Studies were excluded if they involved revision cases, case reports, basic science articles and studies published in non-peer-reviewed journals. Sixteen studies fit inclusion criteria involving 3,305 implants. Overall survival of all implants was found to be 93% with a pooled complication rate of 75.6% using criteria for classifying complications by Glazebrook et al. Previously published classification systems did not clearly define complication categories leading to inconsistency in complication reporting and inaccurate complication rates. There are also several complications that are unclassifiable with the classifications developed by Gadd et al and Glazebrook et al. Our proposed updated classification system provides more inclusive tier profiles to capture the complications that can occur with implants currently on the market. Furthermore, this system provides a stratification of risk that these complications pose to ultimate procedure success.