What's up with WhatsApp in supplementing surgical education: an objective assessment

This is the first study aimed at objectively quantifying the benefit of virtual education using WhatsApp-based discussion groups.

A prospective, non-randomised interventional study was undertaken in the Department of General Surgery, at a tertiary care centre in Kolkata, India, with 200 undergraduate students over a period of 5 days each for 2 weeks, with the first week acting as a control arm. A WhatsApp group was created consisting of 197 eligible undergraduates, faculty members and the authors of this study. Each day, three questions were posted on this group. The second week involved an hour-long WhatsApp-based discussion between the participants and the faculty. Responses were recorded and compared for improvements between the two weeks. Participant feedback was collected and analysed.

Statistically significant improvements were observed in the study group compared with the control group in rates of one in three, two in three and three in three correct responses (p=0.01649, 0.01146 and 0.00946, respectively). A total of 68 (51.92%) feedback respondents were satisfied with the programme. Convenience of use was the principal reason behind satisfaction in 79 respondents (60.31%), whereas 62 participants (47.33%) reported lack of hands-on training as a major drawback.

WhatsApp was found to be a satisfactory supplement to traditional medical teaching. It can be implemented to fill lapses in medical education, especially in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has caused great disruption to traditional teaching methods. Research is needed to assess the feasibility of incorporating it into the curriculum.