A Morphological Basis for Assessing the Phylogeny of the "Tenrecoidea" (Mammalia, Lipotyphla)

A phylogenetic analysis of 35 mammalian taxa focusing on the lipotyphlan family Tenrecidae, based on 193 morphological character states across 71 characters, is undertaken to test several hypotheses of lipotyphlan relationships, including monophyly of the Lipotyphla, Tenrecidae, Malagasy Tenrecidae, and Caribbean Lipotyphla. Explicit tests of these hypotheses are central to understanding larger issues concerning Malagasy and Caribbean biogeography, in addition to mammalian phylogeny. Methodologically, several different parameters are created with which to determine the sensitivity of resulting clades to initial assumptions about a posteriori character weighting, missing data, and multistate character ordering. Clades produced by this data set that appear despite perturbations in these parameters and that are supported by other confidence-assessment techniques contradict Malagasy tenrecid monophyly and the association of soricids with the Caribbean taxon Solenodon. Results regarding tenrecid and lipotyphlan monophyly are more ambiguous and depend on certain assumptions regarding treatment of character ordering, weighting, and missing data. An alternative phylogeny supporting an African mammal clade receives no support from the data set discussed herein.