Turbulent-like velocity fluctuations in two-dimensional granular materials subject to cyclic shear

We perform a systematic experimental study to investigate the velocity fluctuations in the two-dimensional granular matter of low and high friction coefficients subjected to cyclic shear of a range of shear amplitudes, whose velocity fields are strikingly turbulent-like with vortices of different scales. The scaling behaviors of both the transverse velocity power spectra E_T(k) ∝ k^- and, more severely, the longitudinal velocity power spectra E_L(k) ∝ k^- are affected by the prominent peak centered around k ≈ 2π of the inter-particle distance due to the static structure factor of the hard-particle nature in contrast to the real turbulence. To reduce the strong peak effect to the actual values of α (the subscript 'ν' refers to either T or L), we subsequently analyze the second-order velocity structure functions of S(2)ν(r) in real space, which show the power-law scalings of S(2)ν(r) ∝ r for both modes. From the values of β, we deduce the corresponding α from the scaling relations of α = β + 2. The deduced values of α increase continuously with the shear amplitude γ_m, showing no signature of yielding transition, and are slightly larger than α = 2.0 at the limit of γ_m → 0, which corresponds to the elastic limit of the system, for all γ_m. The inter-particle friction coefficients show no significant effect on the turbulent-like velocity fluctuations. Our findings suggest that the turbulent-like collective particle motions are governed by both the elasticity and plasticity in cyclically sheared granular materials.