Moisture content and material density affects severity of frost damage in earthen heritage

Successful conservation of earthen heritage requires an understanding of interactions between environmental and climatic conditions, soil-based materials and human interventions. Frost cycling is likely to be an important contributor to the deterioration of earthen heritage, with frost damage known to cause deterioration features such as flaking and granular disintegration. However, it is not clear how important a contribution frost cycling makes in comparison with other agents. Previous earthen heritage studies have focused on other agents of deterioration, such as wind and rain, or investigated the role of freeze-thaw cycles under conditions unrepresentative of many earthen sites. We investigate how density and moisture content affect the severity of frost damage on earthen heritage using materials and conditions informed by those found at earthen sites in NW China. We prepared rammed earth cubes (5 × 5 × 5 cm) at two densities (1.65 and 1.75 g cm^-3) and with five moisture content levels between 0.46 and 8%. Samples were subjected to 80 freeze-thaw temperature cycles (+7 to -15 °C) in an environmental cabinet. Deterioration was recorded using visual assessment, measurements of surface roughness, ultrasonic pulse velocities, a Vicat needle test and mass loss. Results showed frost damage was dependent on moisture content and density of rammed earth samples. Samples with <2% moisture content showed no visible frost damage. Samples with higher moisture contents (>6%) and higher densities exhibited the greatest deterioration with surface granulation, salt efflorescence and flakes detaching from the parent cubes. This suggests that frost damage to rammed earth is likely to be focused in periods when rainfall or snowmelt is followed by freeze-thaw temperature cycling. In addition, results suggest that if higher density earthen materials are used for repairs or restoration for sites in dryland environments, these could be more vulnerable to frost damage than lower density materials.