Outcomes of First Metacarpal Extension Osteotomy for Base of Thumb Arthritis

First metacarpal extension osteotomy (FMEO) aims to correct the adduction deformity associated with thumb arthritis, as well as improve the congruity at the first carpometacarpal (FCMC) joint. However, the benefits of this procedure are currently unclear. The purpose of this study is to investigate the outcomes of FMEO in the treatment of FCMC joint arthritis.

Electronic databases were searched systematically for original data studies in the English language reporting outcomes following FMEO for base of thumb arthritis. Data were extracted from the text, tables, and figures of publications and meta-analyzed where possible.

Ten publications comprising 211 thumbs were included. FMEO was associated with an improvement in pain relief and patient-reported functional outcomes, however meta-analysis showed no significant long-term improvement in grip strength or lateral pinch grip. Although there was disease progression in one third of patients after FMEO, most did not require further procedures. Outcomes following secondary procedures was not analyzed in the literature. FMEO produced a range of minor complications, however, major complications were rare.

The available evidence suggests FMEO does not improve grip or pinch strength. However, it may have a role in analgesia and improvement in functional outcomes. Further studies should compare outcomes of FMEO to continued nonoperative treatment, or other surgical options including arthroscopy or ligamentous reconstruction.