Trans-vaginal ultrasound simulation: An exploratory qualitative research study focused on the end-users perception of...

Simulation has been shown to be beneficial and effective in the intimate educational setting of trans-vaginal ultrasound (TVUS). In addition, quantitative work has shown dyad learning (learning in pairs) to be non-inferior to independent learning simulation in this setting. This study aims to explore trainees' perceptions of learning in TVUS using qualitative research methods. A second aim was to study trainees' perceptions of the method of training, (learning in pairs (dyads) or as individuals).

A three-hour training session using the transvaginal simulator and teaching programme was offered to participants, who either trained individually or as a dyad. Participants were then interviewed using a semi-structured interview technique. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, entered a qualitative research database (NVivo) to allow coding, structured analysis of data and development of themes using Thematic Analysis.

Fifteen doctors with no previous experience in TVUS were assigned simulation training either as individuals (n = 7) or dyads (n = 4 pairs, eight people in total). All participants reported the beneficial nature of simulation training and felt they had sufficient time to meet their learning needs. Some frustration was reported with feedback and the repetitive nature of the simulation. For dyad learning, participants perceived the value of the use of a second person to act as a "sound board", to problem solve and to encourage each other. Independent learners reported frustration and difficulty in understanding if and how something went wrong. However, individual learners had the advantage of being able to go at their own pace.

Previous studies have shown that simulation is effective for training in transvaginal ultrasound. This qualitative research study supports findings of previous quantitative studies by showing that participants appreciated the value of simulation and provided feedback for improvement in educational content. Clinicians and educators providing transvaginal simulation training could consider dyad training as an efficient and educational option, with individual training reserved for those who may need more time.