The decreased incidence of aseptic necrosis in renal transplant recipients--a case control study

Before 1971 the incidence of aseptic necrosis in renal transplant recipients was 29%, and after 1971 it was 5%. To investigate the reasons for this decreased incidence and to elucidate the causes of aseptic necrosis we studied all 26 transplant patients with aseptic necrosis and 42 controls matched for year of transplantation, age, and sex. Development of aseptic necrosis was not related to duration of dialysis before transplant, severity of uremia at the time the patient started dialysis, adequacy of dialysis before transplantation, transplant dysfunction at the time aseptic necrosis was diagnosed, hyperparathyroidism before or after transplantation, lack of Vitamin D supplementation after transplantation, or fatty infiltration of liver. Total steroid dose 1 month after transplantation was actually lower in aseptic necrosis compared with the control group (2.47 +/- 0.3 g vs. 3.6 +/- 0.3 g SEM g) and was similar after 4 months (6.72 +/- 0.55 g vs. 7.14 +/- 0.6 g), as were total numbers of i.v. doses of methylprednisolone or hydrocortisone. However, blood urea nitrogen (BUN) during the dialysis period was significantly higher in the aseptic necrosis group. Of the aseptic necrosis group, 27% had a previous transplant compared with 5% of controls. Half the aseptic necrosis group (5/10) had parenchymal iron on liver biopsy one year after transplant compared with 15% (2/13) of those without aseptic necrosis. Patients transplanted before 1971 (with and without aseptic necrosis) received significantly more i.v. hydrocortisone and less i.v. methylprednisolone, had higher BUN levels at the time of starting dialysis, and had lower serum calcium and higher serum phosphate at transplantation compared with patients transplanted in or after 1971. The incidence of aseptic necrosis following transplantation has decreased during the past 13 years for reasons that are unclear. Risk factors for aseptic necrosis may include previous transplantation, severe iron overload that may lead to marrow fibrosis and osteopenia, and increased protein catabolism/turnover during dialysis.