Diathesis-stress or differential susceptibility? Comparing the theories when determining the outcomes for children
Jacqueline F Gould1, Carolyn Di Fiore2, Paul Williamson2
1South Australian Health and Medical Research Institute (Women & Kids), 72 King William Road, North Adelaide, South Australia 5006, Australia.
Insights
Preterm infants face higher risks for cognitive and behavioral issues. A supportive home environment may mitigate these risks, though neither diathesis-stress nor differential susceptibility theories were fully supported in this study.
Area of Science:
- Developmental Psychology
- Pediatric Neurology
- Child Development
Background:
- Infants born preterm (<37 weeks gestation) exhibit increased risks for suboptimal cognitive and behavioral outcomes compared to term-born infants.
- The severity of adverse outcomes correlates with decreased gestational age at birth.
- Postnatal environmental factors may play a crucial role in shaping developmental trajectories for preterm infants.
Purpose of the Study:
- To compare the diathesis-stress and differential susceptibility theories in preterm infants.
- To investigate the interaction between prematurity and home environment on long-term cognitive and behavioral outcomes.
- To explore potential environmental interventions for improving outcomes in children born preterm.
Main Methods:
- Study included 535 children born before 33 weeks' gestation.
- Assessed the home environment at 18 months using the Home Screening Questionnaire.
- Evaluated cognitive function (Intelligence Quotient) and behavior (Total Difficulties Score) at 7 years of age.
Main Results:
- No conclusive evidence was found to support either the diathesis-stress or differential susceptibility theories.
- A supportive and stimulating home environment was associated with a reduced risk or severity of suboptimal cognitive and behavioral scores.
- The degree of prematurity did not significantly interact with the home environment to predict outcomes in the tested theoretical frameworks.
Conclusions:
- While theoretical models were not strongly supported, environmental interventions focusing on the home setting show promise.
- A positive home environment may offer a protective effect for preterm infants' cognitive and behavioral development.
- Further research is warranted to develop evidence-based interventions to enhance the home environment for preterm children.
Abstract:
Infants born preterm (less than 37 weeks completed gestation) have a higher risk of suboptimal cognitive and behavioral outcomes when compared with their term-born counterparts. The risk and severity of poor outcome increases as gestational age at birth decreases; however, not all children born preterm will develop deficits, and environmental influences post birth may have a role in shaping developmental outcomes. Whilst early preterm birth is not preventable, it may be possible to intervene after birth via the environment in order to improve outcomes. The diathesis-stress theory hypothesizes that vulnerable individuals will have worse outcomes after a negative environmental exposure, whereas the differential susceptibility theory posits that vulnerable (or plastic) individuals can be both adversely and positively affected by environmental factors. These two theories were compared in 535 children born <33 weeks' gestation. The interaction between the degree of prematurity and the home environment (as measured by the Home Screening Questionnaire) at 18 months on cognition (Intelligence Quotient from the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence) and behavior (Total Difficulties Score from the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire) at 7 years was explored. Evidence was not found for either theory, although a supportive/stimulating home environment appeared to contribute to a decrease in the risk or severity of suboptimal scores. Future research is needed to establish stronger evidence in order to inform interventions to improve the home environment of children born preterm.
Related Concept Videos
Psychological and Sociocultural Causes of Schizophrenia
Introduction to Stress and Lifestyle
Regression Toward the Mean
Nature and Nurture
Psychoneuroimmunology: Cardiovascular Disease
A key area of focus in PNI is the relationship between stress and coronary...
Socioemotional Development during Infancy
Primary Temperament Types


