Molecular Basis for the Interaction of Catalase with d-Penicillamine: Rationalization of Some of Its Deleterious...

d-Penicillamine (d-Pen) is a sulfur compound used in the management of rheumatoid arthritis, Wilson's disease (WD), and alcohol dependence. Many side effects are associated with its use, particularly after long-term treatment. However, the molecular basis for such side effects is poorly understood. Based on the well-known oxidase activity of hemoproteins and the participation of catalase in cellular H₂O₂ redox signaling, we posit that d-Pen could inactivate catalase, thus disturbing H₂O₂ levels. Herein, we report on the molecular basis that could partly explain the side effects associated with this drug compound, and we demonstrate that it induces the formation of compound II, a temporarily inactive state of the enzyme, through two distinct mechanisms. Initially, d-Pen reacts with native catalase and/or iron metal ions, used to mimic non-heme iron overload observed in long-term treated WD patients, to generate thiyl radicals. These radicals partake in a futile redox cycle, thus producing superoxide radical anions O₂^•- and hydrogen peroxide H₂O₂. Then, either H₂O₂ unexpectedly reacts with reduced CAT-Fe(II) to produce compound II or both aforementioned reactive oxygen species intervene in compound II generation through compound I formation and then reduction. These findings support the evidence that d-Pen could perturb H₂O₂ redox homeostasis through transient but recurring catalase inactivation, which may in part rationalize some deleterious effects observed with this therapeutic agent, as discussed.