Utility of renal scintigraphy in diagnosis of multicystic dysplastic kidney

To compare the prevalence of vesicoureteral reflux (VUR), febrile urinary tract infection (fUTI), and chronic kidney disease (CKD) among patients with multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) diagnosed by renal scintigraphy (RS) versus follow-up renal ultrasound (RUS) alone.

This was a retrospective review of patients seen at a tertiary care center from 2010 to 2020 with MCDK diagnosed by RS or follow-up RUS. Differences in the prevalence of VUR, fUTI, and CKD by cohort were assessed using logistic regression analysis, Pearson X² , and Fisher's Exact tests. Temporal trends in diagnostic methods used (RUS versus RUS + RS) were evaluated using the Cochran-Armitage trend test.

One-hundred seventy-two patients were included: 50% (n = 86) underwent RUS + RS and 50% (n = 86) underwent RUS alone to diagnose MCDK. Prevalence of VUR, fUTI, and CKD did not significantly vary between groups. Among patients who had a VCUG, 4.4% had contralateral VUR (1.7% RUS + RS group; 7.4% RUS group; p = 0.19) and 14.5% had at least one fUTI (16.3% RUS + RS group; 12.8% RUS group; p = 0.52). Females were significantly more likely to have at least one fUTI (p = 0.04). Four patients (2.3%) developed CKD, all in the RUS + RS cohort (p = 0.12). Diagnosis of MCDK by RUS versus RUS + RS did not significantly vary over time (p = 0.17).

Patients with unilateral MCDK confirmed by RS versus RUS alone do not significantly vary in the prevalence of VUR, fUTI, or CKD. Renal scintigraphy studies may not be necessary in unilateral MCDK diagnosis but continue to be used.