The Nonmonotonic Dose Dependence of Protein Expression in Cells Transfected with Self-Amplifying RNA

Self-amplifying (sa) RNA molecules-"replicons"-derived from the genomes of positive-sense RNA viruses are receiving increasing attention as gene and vaccine delivery vehicles. This is because mRNA forms of genes of interest can be incorporated into them and strongly amplified, thereby enhancing target protein expression. In this report, we demonstrate a nonmonotonic dependence of protein expression on the mass of transfected replicon, in contrast to the usual, monotonic case of non-saRNA transfections. We lipotransfected a variety of cell lines with increasing masses of enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (eYFP) as a reporter gene in sa form and found that there is a "sweet spot" at which protein expression and cell viability are optimum. To control the varying mass of transfected replicon RNA for a given mass of Lipofectamine, the replicons were mixed with a "carrier" RNA that is neither replicated nor translated; the total mass of transfected RNA was kept constant while increasing the fraction of the replicon from zero to one. Fluorescence microscopy studies showed that the optimum protein expression and cell viability are achieved for replicon fractions as small as 1/10 of the total transfected RNA, and these results were quantified by a systematic series of flow cytometry measurements. IMPORTANCE Positive-sense RNA viruses often have a cytotoxic effect on their host cell because of the strength of their RNA replicase proteins, even though only one copy of their genome begins the viral life cycle in each cell. Noninfectious forms of them-replicons-which include just their RNA replication-related genes, are also strongly self-amplifying and cytotoxic. Accordingly, when replicons fused with nonviral genes of interest are transfected into cells to amplify expression of proteins of interest, one needs to keep the replicon "dose" sufficiently low. We demonstrate how to control the number of RNA replicons getting into transfected cells and that there is a sweet spot for the replicon dose that optimizes protein expression and cell viability. Examples are given for the case of Nodamura viral replicons with fluorescent protein reporter genes in a variety of mammalian cell lines, quantified by flow cytometry and live/dead cell assays.