The Prevalence and Importance of Semiformal Organizations and Semiformal Control in Rural China: Insights from a
Shanhe Jiang1, Dawei Zhang2, Darrell D Irwin3
1Department of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Wayne State University, 656 W Kirby St., Detroit, MI 48202 USA.
Abstract:
This analysis of data collected from a nationwide survey in 2021 focused on the prevalence and importance of different forms of social control particularly semiformal social control in community order maintenance within rural China. Scholars have a growing interest in China's semiformal control. However, prior studies lack quantitative research on the prevalence and importance of this semiformal control. Employing quantitative analysis, this study found that China uses a trinary (formal, semiformal, and informal) control system to maintain social order as contrasted with a Western binary (formal vs. informal) control system. Overall, semiformal organizations-village committees-are more prevalent and important than formal control mechanisms such as government and police and informal control mechanisms such as xiangxian or kin or kin-kind community leaders. Furthermore, the relative prevalence and importance of semiformal organizations and control are found to be associated with types of social order maintenance activities. These findings are meaningful for testing the generalizability of social disorganization theory and developing a China- or Asian-centric control theory.
Related Concept Videos
Relationship Formation
Close Relationships and Culture
Conduct Disorder
Naturalistic Observations
Impact of Social Context on Individuals
Socioemotional Experience and Gender Development


