Spin Alternation Rule in USCF for Through-Bond Magnetic Coupling─A New Look: Why and When Does It Arise and How To...

This work takes a new look at the spin alternation rule in unrestricted self-consistent-field (USCF) calculations in terms of structural characteristics such as periodicity, impurity location, and Coulomb exchange. For clarity, the systems considered are biradicals produced from linear conjugated hydrocarbons. Both site-parametrized Hamiltonian models for theoretical analysis and spin unrestricted density functional theory (DFT) calculations are used. Theoretical analysis leads to the following conclusions: (1) The diradical state is an excited state of a linear chain of N conjugated carbon atoms (when N is about ≤ 10). Spin alternation is a consequence of the (truncated) periodic symmetry combined with filling each closed-shell pi orbital with two electrons and each singly occupied molecular orbital (SOMO) with one electron. Spin polarization is evident in triplet (T) and broken symmetry (BS) solutions for an odd N and only in the T solution for an even N. Spin alternation is visible in the BS for an odd N and always remains muted in the calculated T. (2) For a doped chain with two radical centers, spin alternation is generally visible in the BS for an odd N. The sign of spin population on the radical centers in the BS indicates the stable spin. For radical centers separated by an odd (even) number of p electrons, spin alternation favors T (S) state with FM (AFM) interaction. Spin oscillation remains less transparent for an even N without exchange. (3) In an unrestricted treatment with exchange, spin alternation becomes observable. Without SCF iterations, the more stable state can be identified from a clear spin oscillation in the BS. An irregular oscillation indicates a possible singlet ground state. These observations are supported by density functional calculations using the B3LYP functional and the 6-311+g(d,p) basis set on linear decapentaene diradicals with nitronyl nitroxide moieties substituted on two sets of conjugated atoms, (3,9) and (3,10). Because of the SCF procedure, one finds spin alternation in the T (BS) solution and erratic oscillation in the BS (T) solution of the 3,9 (3,10) diradical in respective equilibrium geometries. The ground state is T (S). DFT adiabatic coupling constants, SOMO energies, spin population plots, and SOMO lobe diagrams compare well with molecular electronic characteristics from theoretical analysis using Hamiltonian parameters.