Mechanical properties of polycaprolactone (PCL) scaffolds for hybrid 3D-bioprinting with alginate-gelatin hydrogel

The generation of artificial human tissue by 3D-bioprinting has expanded significantly as a clinically relevant research topic in recent years. However, to produce a complex and viable tissue, in-depth biological understanding and advanced printing techniques are required with a high number of process parameters. Here, we systematically evaluate the process parameters relevant for a hybrid bioprinting process based on fused-deposition modeling (FDM) of thermoplastic material and microextrusion of a cell-laden hydrogel. First, we investigated the effect of the printing temperature of polycaprolactone (PCL), on the junction strength between individual fused filaments and on the viability of immortalized mesenchymal stem cells (iMSC) in the surrounding alginate-gelatin-hydrogel. It was found that a printing temperature of 140 °C and bonds with an angle of 90° between the filaments provided a good compromise between bonding strength of the filaments and the viability of the surrounding cells. Using these process parameters obtained from individual fused filaments, we then printed cubic test structures with a volume of 10 × 10 × 10 mm³ with different designs of infill patterns. The variations in mechanical strength of these cubes were measured for scaffolds made of PCL-only as well as for hydrogel-filled PCL scaffolds printed by alternating hybrid bioprinting of PCL and hydrogel, layer by layer. The bare scaffolds showed a compressive modulus of up to 6 MPa, close to human hard tissue, that decreased to about 4 MPa when PCL was printed together with hydrogel. The scaffold design suited best for hybrid printing was incubated with cell-laden hydrogel and showed no degradation of its mechanical strength for up to 28 days.