Concerted and Stepwise Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer for Tryptophan-Derivative Oxidation with Water as the Primary...

Concerted electron-proton transfer (CEPT) reactions avoid charged intermediates and may be energetically favorable for redox and radical-transfer reactions in natural and synthetic systems. Tryptophan (W) often partakes in radical-transfer chains in nature but has been proposed to only undergo sequential electron transfer followed by proton transfer when water is the primary proton acceptor. Nevertheless, our group has shown that oxidation of freely solvated tyrosine and W often exhibit weakly pH-dependent proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) rate constants with moderate kinetic isotope effects (KIE ≈ 2-5), which could be associated with a CEPT mechanism. These results and conclusions have been questioned. Here, we present PCET rate constants for W derivatives with oxidized Ru- and Zn-porphyrin photosensitizers, extracted from laser flash-quench studies. Alternative quenching/photo-oxidation methods were used to avoid complications of previous studies, and both the amine and carboxylic acid groups of W were protected to make the indole the only deprotonable group. With a suitably tuned oxidant strength, we found an ET-limited reaction at pH < 4 and weakly pH-dependent rates at pH > ∼5 that are intrinsic to the PCET of the indole group with water (H₂O) as the proton acceptor. The observed rate constants are up to more than 100 times higher than those measured for initial electron transfer, excluding the electron-first mechanism. Instead, the reaction can be attributed to CEPT. These conclusions are important for our view of CEPT in water and of PCET-mediated radical reactions with solvent-exposed tryptophan in natural systems.