Evaluation of deviation in implants placed at different depths with a prototype surgical guide: an in vitro study

The aim of this study was to measure the angular and linear deviations between planned and placed dental implant positions at different depths in an in vitro model. Ten dental manikins of a maxilla without the central and lateral incisors were used. The implants were placed in the tooth positions using a prototype guide based on computed tomographic scans of dental casts. The groups consisted of implants placed at varying depths according to tooth position: 1 mm deep for the right lateral incisor, 2 mm deep for the right central incisor, 3 mm deep for the left central incisor, and 4 mm deep for the left lateral incisor (n = 10 per group). After implant placement, the manikin was scanned again to compare the positioning of the implants to the planned positions. Statistical analysis evaluated the linear deviations between planned and placed implant positions at 3 points (coronal, central, and apical) as well as the angular discrepancies. The analysis showed that the depth of the implant placement proportionally affected the linear deviation of the actual position from the planned position; thus, the deeper implants showed significantly greater linear deviations (P < 0.05; 1-way analysis of variance and Tukey test). There were no statistically significant differences in the mean angular deviations of the groups. Thus, the results suggest that implants placed at greater depths present greater linear deviations than implants placed at shallower depths, but the angular deviation is not affected by implant depth.