Related Experiment Video
Updated: Sep 25, 2025

Models and Methods to Evaluate Transport of Drug Delivery Systems Across Cellular Barriers
Published on: October 17, 2013
Multiple nutrient transporters enable cells to mitigate a rate-affinity tradeoff.
Luis Fernando Montaño-Gutierrez1, Kevin Correia1, Peter S Swain1
1School of Biological Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Cells use multiple nutrient transporters to overcome a fundamental biological tradeoff. This rate-affinity tradeoff allows cells to optimize nutrient uptake across varying environmental conditions, ensuring survival.
Area of Science:
- Molecular Biology
- Biophysics
- Systems Biology
Background:
- Eukaryotic genomes frequently encode multiple transporters for identical nutrients, such as the 17 hexose transporters (HXTs) in budding yeast for glucose transport.
- Cellular nutrient uptake is crucial for survival and is mediated by various transport mechanisms, including facilitated diffusion and symport.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the rate-affinity tradeoff in nutrient transporters and its implications for cellular nutrient uptake.
- To determine if cells utilize multiple transporters to mitigate this tradeoff under different nutrient concentrations.
Main Methods:
- Mathematical modeling was employed to analyze the relationship between transport rate, affinity, and import flux.
- Fluorescent tagging of seven HXT genes in budding yeast was used to monitor transporter expression dynamics.
- Experimental data on HXT gene expression was compared with known transporter affinities.
Main Results:
- Mathematical models predicted a non-monotonic relationship between transporter characteristics and import flux, with optimal transporters for specific nutrient concentrations.
- Transporter regulation in budding yeast, particularly HXT gene expression in response to falling glucose levels, aligns with the predicted rate-affinity tradeoff.
- The order of transporter expression as glucose levels decrease generally follows their affinity for glucose, supporting the tradeoff hypothesis.
Conclusions:
- The rate-affinity tradeoff is a significant constraint in the evolution of nutrient transporters.
- Cells can strategically employ multiple transporters with varying affinities to optimize nutrient import across diverse environmental conditions.
- This study provides evidence for a common evolutionary tradeoff in cellular nutrient transport mechanisms.
Related Concept Videos
Carrier-Mediated Transport
Active transport involves two types of membrane-spanning transporters: uptake and efflux. Uptake transporters are expressed in the small...
Membrane Transporters
Transporters are mainly composed of alpha-helices, built from bundles of ten or more helices traversing the plasma membrane. The solute-binding sites are located midway, where some of the helices are broken or distorted, making space for the binding site through...
Facilitated Diffusion
In this process, substrates such as organic compounds and ions interact with a transporter on one side, triggering conformational changes in proteins that enable...
Active Transport
Primary active transporters, like Na+, K+ and -ATPase, directly utilize ATP to move ions across the membrane. These transporters play significant roles in various physiological processes. For instance, Na+, K+ and -ATPase maintain...
Drug Absorption Mechanism: Carrier-Mediated Membrane Transport
Facilitated diffusion is a passive process that utilizes human Solute Carrier (SLC) transporters. These transporters bind to the drug, undergo structural...
Cellular Membranes and Drug Transport
Phospholipids arrange themselves into a bilayer, with hydrophilic heads oriented outward and hydrophobic tails facing inward.

