Impact of Bicarbonate Interference on Routine Ion-Selective Electrode Chloride Measurements

Chloride measurement is crucial for calculating the anion gap. Bicarbonate can interfere with chloride measurements; however, there is no information on the specific types of electrodes affected or the changes in bicarbonate non-selectivity over time. We evaluated the interference of bicarbonate on chloride measurements using different electrodes and the stability of this interference over time.

The effect of bicarbonate on chloride measured with electrodes of various manufacturers was assessed. When non-selectivity toward bicarbonate was observed, the stability of this interference during the electrode's lifetime was explored. The impact of the bicarbonate concentration on the calibrator was also evaluated.

Non-selectivity was observed for electrodes using quaternary ammonium salts (Beckman Coulter, Siemens, and Roche), with overestimated or underestimated chloride values observed at high or low bicarbonate concentrations, respectively. The degree of selectivity varied among electrodes. With the Roche electrode, interference became more pronounced over time, whereas the Siemens electrode appeared to gain selectivity during its lifetime. For the Roche system, adjusting the calibrator's bicarbonate concentration from 30 mmol/L to 20-24 mmol/L reduced the number of samples with unacceptable bias (>3%) from 77.3% to 12.6%. Lot-to-lot variations in the calibrator bicarbonate concentration increased the uncertainty of chloride measurements.

The extent of bicarbonate-induced error varied according to the type, manufacturer, and wear of the electrode; the bicarbonate concentration in the calibrators and the tested sample; and the chloride content. Laboratories should be aware of the impact of bicarbonate on routine chloride measurements to establish appropriate QC procedures.