Comparison of Antibodies to Detect Uroplakin in Urothelial Carcinomas

Immunohistochemistry for Uroplakin (UP) II and III is used to determine urothelial origin of carcinomas of unknown primary site and are especially valuable to differentiate urothelial carcinomas (UCs) from lung squamous cell carcinomas and prostate carcinomas. In the Nordic immunohistochemical Quality Control assessment scheme, only 45% of the participants obtained a sufficient staining result for UP. Primary antibodies (Abs) against UPII were most successful with a pass rate of 86%. No Abs against UPIII provided sufficient staining results. A comparative study was carried out on a larger cohort of tissue samples with optimized methods for the UPII mouse monoclonal antibody (mmAb) clone BC21, UPIII mmAb clone AU-1, and rabbit monoclonal antibody (rmAb) clone SP73 to evaluate the performance in a standardized way. Tissue microarrays containing 58 UCs, 111 non-UCs, and 20 normal tissues were included. The UP stains were evaluated by using H-score. Based on H-scores, samples were categorized as high-expressor (150 to 300), moderate-expressor (10 to 149), low-expressor (1 to 9), and negative (<1). The UPII mmAb clone BC21 obtained a significant higher analytical sensitivity of 69% for UCs compared with the UPIII Abs mmAb clone AU-1 and rmAb clone SP73 with 19% and 29%, respectively. No high-expressor UCs were seen for the UPIII Abs, whereas 13% of the positive UCs obtained an H-score >150 for the UPII Ab. The 2 UPIII Abs gave an analytical specificity of 100% compared with 97% for the UPII Ab being positive in 2 ovarian carcinomas and 1 cervical squamous cell carcinoma.