Kidney Organoids Are Capable of Forming Tumors, but Not Teratomas

Induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC)-derived kidney organoids are a potential tool for the regeneration of kidney tissue. They represent an early stage of nephrogenesis and have been shown to successfsully vascularize and mature further in vivo. However, there are concerns regarding the long-term safety and stability of iPSC derivatives. Specifically, the potential for tumorigenesis may impede the road to clinical application. To study safety and stability of kidney organoids, we analyzed their potential for malignant transformation in a teratoma assay and following long-term subcutaneous implantation in an immune-deficient mouse model. We did not detect fully functional residual iPSCs in the kidney organoids as analyzed by gene expression analysis, single-cell sequencing and immunohistochemistry. Accordingly, kidney organoids failed to form teratoma. Upon long-term subcutaneous implantation of whole organoids in immunodeficient IL2Ry-/-RAG2-/- mice, we observed tumor formation in 5 out of 103 implanted kidney organoids. These tumors were composed of WT1+CD56+ immature blastemal cells and showed histological resemblance with Wilms tumor. No genetic changes were identified that contributed to the occurrence of tumorigenic cells within the kidney organoids. However, assessment of epigenetic changes revealed a unique cluster of differentially methylated genes that were also present in undifferentiated iPSCs. We discovered that kidney organoids have the capacity to form tumors upon long-term implantation. The presence of epigenetic modifications combined with the lack of environmental cues may have caused an arrest in terminal differentiation. Our results indicate that the safe implementation of kidney organoids should exclude the presence of pro-tumorigenic methylation in kidney organoids.