Optimal definitions for computing HKA angle in caos: an in-vitro comparison study

Guillaume Dardenne1,2, Bhushan Borotikar1,2, Hoel Letissier1,2,3

  • 1CHU Brest, Brest, France.

Insights

This study compared methods for estimating the Knee Center (KC) and Frontal Plane (FP) in Computer Assisted Orthopedic Surgery (CAOS) to determine the Hip-Knee-Ankle Angle (HKAA). The helical approach for FP and either the notch or tibial spines for KC offered the best accuracy and precision for HKAA measurement.

Area of Science:

  • Orthopedic Surgery
  • Biomechanical Engineering
  • Medical Imaging

Background:

  • Accurate determination of the Hip-Knee-Ankle Angle (HKAA) is crucial in Computer Assisted Orthopedic Surgery (CAOS).
  • Existing methods for estimating the Knee Center (KC) and Frontal Plane (FP) vary in precision and accuracy.
  • Standardization of these estimations is needed for reliable HKAA measurements.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To compare the precision and accuracy of nine KC and seven FP estimation methods in CAOS.
  • To identify the optimal combination of KC and FP methods for precise HKAA determination.
  • To evaluate the performance of different CAOS software algorithms for HKAA calculation.

Main Methods:

  • An in-vitro experiment using thirteen cadaveric lower limbs.
  • Development of a CAOS software application to compute HKAA.
  • Measurement of HKAA precision and accuracy using nine KC and seven FP methods, including the helical approach.

Main Results:

  • The helical method for FP determination yielded the highest HKAA precision.
  • The highest HKAA accuracy was achieved using the helical approach for FP and either the notch or tibial spines for KC.
  • Specific combinations of FP and KC methods were identified for optimal HKAA estimation.

Conclusions:

  • The helical approach for FP determination combined with the notch or tibial spines for KC estimation provides sufficient accuracy and precision for HKAA.
  • This study highlights the importance of method selection for reliable HKAA measurements in CAOS.
  • The findings can guide the development and application of CAOS software for improved orthopedic procedures.