Comparison of three zinc binding groups for HDAC inhibitors - A potency, selectivity and enzymatic kinetics study

Hydroxamic acid and benzamide are the most commonly used zinc binding group (ZBG) for HDAC inhibitors both in clinic and pre-clinic. Recently, we discovered several analogs of new type HDAC inhibitors with hydrazide as ZBG. Representative compounds displayed high potency, class I HDAC selectivity and excellent pharmacokinetics profile. In this research, we synthesize tool compounds 4 and 6 by modifying the hydroxamic acid of SAHA with benzamide and hydrazide, respectively, and compare the potency, isoform selectivity, binding profile and enzymatic kinetics for the hydroxamate, benzamide and hydrazide-based inhibitors. It is well known that SAHA with hydroxamic acid is a pan-HDAC inhibitor with competitive binding and fast-on/fast-off profile. Compound 6 is a slow-binding class I selective inhibitor with mixed (competitive and non-competitive) binding mode, which is the same as the hydrazide inhibitors in our previous study. Compound 4 is a class I selective, fast-on/fast-off inhibitor with competitive binding mode to HDAC1/2/3, which is different with published benzamide MS275 and 106. Therefore, the kinetics profile of benzamide is not only due to the ZBG, but also rely on the cap and linker groups. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report to compare the enzymatic profile of three promising ZBGs of HDAC inhibitors.