Collateral Ligament Ruptures of the Thumb Metacarpophalangeal Joint A Review of 500 Surgical Cases

A retrospective review was conducted of 500 consecutive patients who underwent surgery for complete collateral ligament ruptures of their thumb metacarpophalangeal (MP) joints comprising 362 ulnar collateral and 138 radial collateral ligaments. Complete rupture was confirmed in all cases at surgery. When surgery was carried out within 3 weeks of the injury, reinsertion of the ligament was pos- sible in 98% of cases. When surgery was performed after 3 weeks, reinsertion of the ligament was possible in 45% of ulnar and 68% of radial injuries. Reconstruction utilizing a free tendon graft was required for the other cases. All patients who had surgery within 3 weeks of their injuries regained stable, pain free thumbs. Surgery was less suc- cessful in patients who had surgery after 3 weeks and the failure rate was 5%. Surgery within 3 weeks of the injury permitted re-insertion of the ligament in almost all cases. We propose that avulsions treated within that period be referred to as "acute" injuries and those treated later as "chronic." Treatment of acute injuries is preferred because they rarely require reconstruction, and the results were better than when surgery was performed for chronic injuries. Repair of thumb MP collateral ligaments is predictably possible within 3 weeks of injury but less likely if surgery is delayed after that time period.