Striking Size and Doping Effects of Ti-Si-O Clusters on Methane Conversion Reactions

The size and doping effects in methane activation by Ti-Si-O clusters have been explored by using a combination of gas-phase experiments and quantum chemical calculations. All [Ti_m Si_n O_2(m+n) ]^.+ (m+n=2, 3, 8, 10, 12, 14) clusters can extract a hydrogen from methane. The associated energies and structures have been revealed in detail. Moreover, the doping and size effects have been discussed involving generalized Kohn-Sham energy decomposition analysis, natural population analysis, Wiberg bond indexes (WBI), molecular polarity index (MPI) and ionization potential (IP). It suggested that Ti-Si-O clusters with a low Ti : Si ratio is beneficial to adsorbing methane and inclination to the hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) process, while the clusters with a high Ti : Si ratio favors the generation of a terminal oxygen radical and results in high reactivity and turnover frequency. On the other hand, a cluster size of m+n=12 is recommended considering both the ionization potential and the turnover frequency of the reaction. Hopefully, these finding will be instructive for the design of high-performance Ti-Si-O catalyst toward methane conversion.