Quantitative Data Integration Analysis Method for Cross-Studies: Obstructive Sleep Apnea as an Example

In recent years, the prevalence of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) has gradually increased. The diagnosis of this multiphenotypic disorder requires a combination of several indicators. The objective of this study was to find significant apnea monitor indicators of OSA by developing a strategy for cross-study screening and integration of quantitative data.

Articles related to sleep disorders were obtained from the PubMed database. A sleep disorder dataset and an OSA dataset were manually curated from these articles. Two evaluation indexes, the indicator coverage ratio (ICR) and the study integrity ratio (SIR), were used to filter out OSA indicators from the OSA dataset and create profiles including different numbers of indicators and studies for analysis. Data were analyzed by the meta 4.18-0 package of R, and the p value and standard mean difference (SMD) values were calculated to evaluate the change of each indicator.

The sleep disorder dataset was constructed based on 178 studies from 119 publications, the OSA dataset was extracted from 89 studies, 284 sleep-related indicators were filtered out, and 22 profiles were constructed. Apnea hypopnea index was significantly decreased in all 22 profiles. Total sleep time (TST) (min) showed no significant differences in 21 profiles. There were significant increases in rapid eye movement (REM) (%TST) in 18 profiles, minimum arterial oxygen saturation (SaO₂) in 9 profiles, REM duration in 3 profiles, and slow wave sleep duration (%TST) and pulse oximetry lowest point in 2 profiles. There were significant decreases in apnea index (AI) in 14 profiles; arousal index and SaO₂ < 90 (%TST) in 8 profiles; N1 stage (%TST) in 7 profiles; and hypopnea index, N1 stage (% sleep period time (%SPT)), N2 stage (%SPT), respiratory arousal index, and respiratory disorder index in 2 profiles.

The proposed data integration strategy successfully identified multiple significant OSA indicators.