Quantitative Agreement between Conformational Substates of Holo Calcium-Loaded Calmodulin Detected by Double...

Calcium-loaded calmodulin (CaM/4Ca²⁺) comprises two domains that undergo rigid body reorientation from a predominantly extended conformation to a compact one upon binding target peptides. A recent replica-exchange molecular dynamics (MD) simulation on holo CaM/4Ca²⁺ suggested the existence of distinct structural clusters (substates) along the path from extended to compact conformers in the absence of substrates. Here, we experimentally demonstrate the existence of CaM/4Ca²⁺ substates trapped in local minima by three freezing/annealing regimes (slow, 40 s; intermediate, 1.5 s; fast, 0.5 ms) using pulsed Q-band double electron-electron resonance (DEER) EPR spectroscopy to measure interdomain distances between nitroxide spin-labels positioned at A17C and A128C in the N- and C-terminal domains, respectively. The DEER echo curves were directly fit to population-optimized P(r) pairwise distance distributions calculated from the coordinates of the MD clusters and compact crystal structure. DEER data on fully deuterated CaM/4Ca²⁺ were acquired at multiple values of the second echo period (10-35 micros) and analyzed globally to eliminate instrumental and overfitting artifacts and ensure accurate populations, peak positions, and widths. The DEER data for all three freezing regimes are quantitatively accounted for within experimental error by 5-6 distinct conformers comprising a predominantly populated extended form (60-75%) and progressively more compact states whose populations decrease as the degree of compactness increases. The shortest interdomain separation is found in the compact crystal structure, which has an occupancy of 4-6%. Thus, CaM/4Ca²⁺ samples high energy local minima comprising a few discrete substates of increasing compactness in a rugged energy landscape.