Comparing Fusion Rates Between Fresh-Frozen and Freeze-Dried Allografts in Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion

The objective of this retrospective study is to compare the fusion rates in anterior cervical discectomy and fusion surgery using freeze-dried versus fresh-frozen allografts.

The study comprised 79 patients. Fifty-one patients received freeze-dried allograft (106 total spinal levels) and 28 patients received fresh-frozen allograft (50 total spinal levels). Fusion was assessed through trabecular bridging on follow-up anterior-posterior/lateral radiographs. Trabecular bridging was assessed on the superior and inferior borders of each spinal level and given a fusion grade. Complete fusion is defined as >50% bridging between superior and inferior borders of the bone graft; union is complete fusion in <26 weeks; delayed union is complete fusion after 26 weeks; and fibrous union is <50% bridging at ≥1 borders over 52 weeks.

All spinal levels reached complete fusion for both graft types. Of the freeze-dried treated cervical spinal levels, 77.35% (82/106) reached union (adequate trabecular bridging within 6 months) without delay compared with 80% (35/50) for the fresh-frozen bone graft group (P = 0.85). There was no significant difference in time-to-fusion analysis and no significant association between delayed union and any patient factors. In assessing Neck Disability Index (NDI), freeze-dried allografts did show a significantly greater decrease in NDI scores at 6 months (P = 0.03). At the 1 year follow-up, improvements in NDI were consistent in both allografts (P = 0.9647).

From this study, freeze-dried and fresh-frozen allografts showed comparable rates of union, and both allografts can be used interchangeably for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion.