Physician-Patient Communication in the Orthopedic Clinic: Surgeon-Identified Challenges

Effective communication between the physician and the patient is crucial to quality healthcare. The orthopedic surgery clinic setting provides an environment for cultivating the physician-patient relationship, eliciting diagnostic data, and developing treatment strategies. However, little is known about the orthopedic surgeon perspective on communicating with patients. The purpose of the study was to identify patient communication and care issues faced in the orthopedic surgery clinic setting that physicians categorize as challenging.

All surgeons in the department of orthopedics in a large tertiary care center were invited to respond to an online survey on common communication challenges. Physicians were asked to rate 13 challenges identified by the literature and opinion leaders using a four-point Likert scale ranging from "Not at all challenging" to "Extremely challenging". In addition, the survey included open ended questions regarding common challenges in communicating with patients and types of encounters, and thematic analysis was applied. Mean scores were calculated.

Nineteen orthopedic surgeons completed the survey and were included in the analysis. Orthopedic surgeons identified misaligned expectations for surgical intervention for a nonsurgical diagnosis as the most challenging encounter in the clinic (16/19). Managing postoperative patient expectations (14/19) and communicating with patients who were dissatisfied with their surgical outcome (13/19) were also commonly rated as particularly challenging. Open ended responses echoed these ratings and additional difficulty facilitating patient understanding of complex information as common communication challenges.

Common challenges in the orthopedic clinic often surround managing patient expectations and providing effective explanations, particularly where physicians perceive a surgical intervention as inappropriate for addressing the patient complaint. Identifying these issues can guide training efforts to help orthopedic physicians in managing these and improving communication. These findings can also provide basis for collecting information about communication challenges from orthopedic surgeons across institutions. Level of Evidence: IV.