Osteomalacia and aplastic bone disease in aluminum-related osteodystrophy

The bone histology in patients with chronic renal failure and aluminum-related bone disease does not always show the excess accumulation of unmineralized osteoid (matrix) characteristic of osteomalacia. Frequently, bone aluminum accumulation is associated with normal or reduced amounts of unmineralized osteoid and low bone formation and is referred to as aplastic bone disease. In this study, we compared static and dynamic bone histomorphometric parameters and plasma PTH and aluminum levels in 12 patients with osteomalacia and 18 patients with aplastic bone disease who had been receiving dialysis for the same duration to determine if the difference in osteoid accumulation in these 2 lesions might be explained by differences in aluminum accumulation or PTH levels. The stainable bone surface aluminum level was significantly higher in the patients with osteomalacia compared to that in the group with aplastic bone [61 +/- 5% (+/- SEM) vs. 43 +/- 4%; P less than 0.02]. The rates of bone apposition and bone formation were lower in the group with osteomalacia (P less than 0.01). Plasma amino-terminal PTH was not significantly different in the 2 groups. The increment in plasma aluminum levels after a single infusion of deferoxamine was higher in the osteomalacic group than in the aplastic group, suggesting that the patients with osteomalacia accumulated more total body chelatable aluminum than did those with aplastic bone disease during a comparable length of time on dialysis. We conclude that the excess unmineralized osteoid in aluminum-related osteomalacia results from the high rate of total body aluminum accumulation, which directly causes uncoupling of matrix mineralization and matrix production, independent of PTH levels. Patients with aplastic bone disease who have accumulated lesser amounts of total body aluminum fail to develop excess unmineralized osteoid because production and mineralization of matrix are more closely coupled than in the osteomalacic lesion, despite a decline in osteoblast numbers.