Tillage and manure effects on runoff nitrogen and phosphorus losses from frozen soils

In cold regions, nutrient losses from dairy agroecosystems are a longstanding and recurring problem, especially when manure is applied during winter over snow-covered frozen soils. This study evaluated two tillage (fall chisel tillage [CT] and no-tillage [NT]) and three manure-type management treatments (unmanured control, liquid manure [<5% solids], and solid manure [>20% solids]). The liquid and solid manure used in this study were from the same animal species (Bos taurus) and facility. The six management treatments were field tested in south-central Wisconsin during the winters (November-April) of 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 with a complete factorial design. Seasonal runoff losses were significantly lower from fall CT compared with NT during both seasons. Manure applications (both liquid and solid) on top of snow significantly increased most of the nutrients (NH₄ ⁺ , dissolved reactive phosphorus, total Kjeldahl nitrogen, and total phosphorus) in runoff compared with unmanured control. Irrespective of tillage and multiple runoff events, solid manure was present on the surface for longer periods, potentially releasing nutrients each time it interacted with runoff. In contrast, liquid manure infiltrated the snowpack and was partly lost with snowmelt and infiltrated soil depending upon soil frost and surface conditions. Overall, results indicate that wintertime manure applications over snow-covered frozen soils pose a risk of nutrient loss irrespective of tillage and manure type, but in unavoidable situations, prioritizing tillage × manure type combination can help reduce losses.