Benchtop Evaluation of Miniature Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy Lithotrites

Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) is the preferred treatment for kidney stones >2 cm. While PCNL has traditionally been performed using 24F to 30F access sheaths, there is a trend toward smaller sheaths and scopes to perform mini-PCNL (mPCNL). We performed benchtop assessment of multiple mPCNL lithotrites. One 1 cm³, hard Begostone phantom was placed in a cylinder with four 5.5 mm cylindrical openings to simulate the size of a 16.5F mPCNL sheath. Lithotripsy was performed with the 1.5 and 1.9 mm Trilogy, 1.83 mm ShockPulse, or a 200 μm Holmium:YAG (Ho:YAG) laser. Suction was used for the mechanical lithotrites. The Trilogy probes were set at 50% impact, 6 Hz, 80% ultrasound and 10% suction. The ShockPulse was used at high-power setting with low suction. The 1.9 mm Trilogy probe was used with a 15F mini-nephroscope. The 1.83 mm ShockPulse, 1.5 mm Trilogy and laser fiber were used with a 12F mini-nephroscope. The 120 W holmium laser was set at 0.5 J/70 Hz Moses-Distance. Ten independent runs were performed with modality. Time to complete stone clearance was recorded and mass stone clearance rates were calculated. The Trilogy 1.9 mm showed superior stone clearance rate (11.69 ± 3.68 mg/s) vs the ShockPulse (SP) 1.83 mm (6.29 ± 1.37 mg/s, p = 0.003), the laser fiber (4.73 ± 0.61 mg/s, p < 0.0005), and the Trilogy 1.5 mm (6.84 ± 1.21 mg/s). The 200 μm laser fiber was inferior to all mechanical lithotrites. There was no difference between the 1.5 mm Trilogy and the 1.83 mm ShockPulse (p = 0.772). This translates to 3.9, 4.8, and 8.1 minutes less treatment time vs the 1.5 mm Trilogy, SP, and laser, respectively, for a spherical 1.5 cm diameter calcium oxalate monohydrate stone. Among these four commonly used mPCNL lithotripters, the Trilogy 1.9 mm demonstrated superior stone clearance rates in this benchtop model vs the Ho:YAG laser, 1.83 mm SP, and Trilogy 1.5 mm. Future clinical testing is warranted to evaluate the optimal lithotrite for mPCNL.