Computer modelling of measurement error in longitudinal lung function data

The effect of measurement error on the accuracy of results in two epidemiological study designs involving longitudinal lung function data was assessed using computer modelling. Five realistic data sets (cohorts) were created, each of 400 subjects, half of whom were exposed to an agent whose effects approximated in magnitude that of cigarette smoking. In each cohort, FEV1 decline was modelled after 6, 4 and 2 years of observation with and without error in the measurement of level of FEV1. For each length of observation the effect of exposure on decline was estimated using a follow-up design comparing the FEV1 decline between exposure groups, and a case-control design comparing risk of exposure in subjects in the top 20th percentile of FEV1 decline (cases) to exposure in those in the bottom 20th percentile (controls). For both study designs an exposure effect at p less than or equal to 0.01 could only be consistently detected after 6 years of observation.